Click a word or symbol for its meaning; click an equals sign or the space around a formula for its whole explanation.
Context and central resultsThe classical laws of black-hole mechanics were established in the early 1970s, relating changes in a black hole’s energy to surface gravity and changes in horizon area.
The were established in the early 1970s, relating changes in a black hole’s energy to and changes in , recognized as the classical mechanical analogues of and , respectively. that horizon area is proportional to black-hole entropy, and soon supplied a surface-gravity-based physical temperature, fixing the proportionality constant in Bekenstein’s area-entropy proposal and extending black-hole mechanics into . Later work further extended these connections to and , and showed how gravitational field equations through thermodynamic relations.
This work develops the and by expressing the established through . The selected nonexpanding-null action identifies the force as a length-source response; this . Rindler, Schwarzschild and the de Sitter reference for equilibrium FRW share that stationary construction. The actual screen separately obeys , and under the Einstein–Cai–Kim assignment. Its complete moving-horizon canonical identification remains open. The is this normalized mechanical interpretation and its radius representations, with the established ingredients and overlaps identified in the papers.
From two horizon questions to force, pressure, and work
and share the same for , , , , and . describes a universe that is , with or .
Here denotes the : the mechanical coefficient multiplying a change in .
use , a , and the positive value.
1. The factor of two that raises the questions
We can see a factor of two difference in their .
Equilibrium FRW
Schwarzschild
And this results in a difference in how their mechanical and thermal products and relate to :
Energy identities and changes for equilibrium FRW and Schwarzschild horizons
Horizon
Energy identity
Changes
Equilibrium FRW
Schwarzschild
Where is the in for , given that the contribution appears as ?
What accounts for the of the energy when ?
2. Treating the changing FRW horizon as a whole
relates the change to , using an equilibrium-form . Other formulations include matter work and the changing enclosed volume. The question we want to ask is more specific: since the , , , , and of the entire changing sphere can all be written in terms of the or , can a in the familiar described by the or also be found?
Looking at the through this , we see that given and ,
We can ask how this may play into the mechanics and thermodynamics, and how it may handle the relation . Since every quantity except is already specified, we can first ask which makes the familiar hold for a changing sphere:
Since , we immediately find
Solving for , where is , gives
The same pressure follows directly by differentiating the and with respect to radius. This does not depend on a stationary null horizon.
Given , we can solve for the and find
This is the we found above. The same can now be written as : force times the apparent-horizon radius, with . The and force have a direct place in the changing horizon’s .
3. The FRW results in pressure variables
This relation between and also simplifies the presentation of the . In the spatially flat case, the is , giving
Using the Einstein coupling , the and relations become
Here is the , , and is the , distinct from the . sets the inverse-square of the , while its combination with determines . Expansion accelerates when .
,
becomes
The combination , the , therefore controls how evolves. For , this also gives : the pressure value fixes density, while its evolution retains the matter-pressure information. These are the familiar cosmological relations expressed in horizon-pressure variables. Only the identification assumes ; the relations written in terms of the also apply with .
4. What is shared by the different horizons?
So this and clearly play a role in , but how do they relate to , or the even simpler , given their different energy descriptions? ’s does not need an additional work term in its , though raises the question of what mechanical product accompanies the thermal half in the .
The contribution describes the response at a given . The gives a common mechanical description through the shared and structure:
For , this value is exactly the . The has the same area–rate structure with its own rate and work allocation. Matching values on a horizon family does not automatically identify their independent source variations.
With the , this gives
As is the common mechanical , we can take its to see how it changes:
The coefficient is the familiar , and is the contribution familiar from thermodynamics. The other contribution, , describes a change in the scale. But does not yet display the length or volume displacement we expect in .
5. The natural displacement coordinate
We can look for a natural associated with this complementary contribution. have no spherical like and . Instead, a in flat spacetime has a horizon a away, measured on the observer’s . With , this gives the :
defines a . Its corresponding is . In , this length is also the observer–horizon on the observer’s instantaneous rest slice.
This makes a natural . It expresses the normal acceleration scale as a length, so the potential’s response can take the familiar . The force derived below provides a precise selection: among invertible rate-only coordinates , requiring and fixes , agreeing with . We can use that same coordinate in the other examples— for and for —without requiring a universal proper-distance interpretation. The differential identifies its force coefficient; the supplies the canonical check in its stated setting.
Rewriting the using this length gives
Differentiating , we find
As is now the mechanical , we recognize the contribution as the , with
This generalizes the definition to the three descriptions using the . Our common boundary-potential becomes
The negative length-work contribution is therefore exactly : increasing the appears thermally as a .
Two GR foundations: stationary action and cosmological screen
The can be written directly in acceleration length. For uniform stationary nonexpanding data, a and controlled remaining sources, its coefficient per chosen duration is the . This does not require to equal the whole Hamiltonian. Rindler, stationary Schwarzschild and de Sitter fit the selected action. A de Sitter reference matching an FRW screen’s instantaneous radius and density realizes its equilibrium values in that same action. The evolving FRW screen law follows from the Einstein constraint, Misner–Sharp energy and equilibrium rate assignment; a full action identification for its actual moving worldtube remains separate.
6. The pressure and energy identity
We can now derive the as
This reveals the as
the familiar macroscopic , ;
the , , or ;
part of the ;
the same quadratic acceleration–stress form as the , ;
one third of the in , .
The common is
Where the geometry supplies , as it does for , the boundary-potential becomes
In this , , so and . The length work is already the work associated with the radius of the changing horizon sphere.
7. Returning to the black-hole question
As for , we have
The new force product supplies a mechanical representation of the second equal product in the Schwarzschild mass identity. Both and equal ; they are not two independent energy reservoirs. This answers the original “other half” question at the level of the , while retaining the standard mass first law.
The Schwarzschild work can now refer directly to the same horizon sphere. Since , the : . The same work is
Here is the full black-hole mass, while . The common pressure is still ; the is . Since and , both area and work now describe the same changing horizon sphere.
The potential remains , so the remains . Area and volume are linked by the same . Changing in fixed proportion to describes this horizon-size change; it does not move another surface at .
8. Entropy in mechanical and quantum lengths
Further, we can define the associated with the ,
Given
we have
is therefore times the ratio of the ’s to the of its . Equivalently, it measures the in units of the ’s , . This expresses the usual through the mechanical length and the associated with the same .